Happy October! There’s a stretch of days right about now when the trees start putting on their annual show, and no two years look quite alike. We know the leaves will turn. We just never know which tree goes first.
Markets work the same way, which is another way of saying that investing is not a science. If it were, there would be a formula, we would all run it, and this blog would be one line long.
Instead, markets are built out of people, and people get creative with their investing decisions the moment feelings are involved. We can know the patterns without knowing the sequence. Sitting comfortably in that gap is most of the job.
The Comeback Story That Wasn’t
You may have noticed a new headline making the rounds: Diversification is working again. Diversification is back. It’s the comeback we’ve been waiting for.
At N1 Advisors, we’d like to gently push back on that, because diversification never went anywhere. It didn’t take a sabbatical or lose its touch. The financial press labels strategies based on whatever just happened – which makes for tidy headlines but terrible guidance.
When mega-cap U.S. growth ran the table, diversification looked like dead weight. Now that leadership has broadened, the same commentators have declared it rehabilitated. But if diversification only sounds smart once the quieter parts of the market start winning, you’re grading it on the same short-term scoreboard it was built to protect you from.
What Actually Changed
Since the Great Recession, large U.S. companies, technology names in particular, have significantly dominated the market, while international holdings have lagged. For years, that gap prompted a very reasonable question from thoughtful people: why own the other stuff at all?
Then, last year, international outperformed the U.S. This year, the two are running nearly neck and neck, and mid and small cap companies, overlooked for a good while, are showing greater gains.
Here is the part worth understanding about all of this: Nothing broke and nothing got fixed. Leadership simply moved, the way it almost always eventually does. A diversified portfolio isn’t “working” only when everything wins at once, or when the parts that trailed finally get their turn. Its purpose is to reduce your dependence on any single outcome, which it was doing faithfully during all those years it may have appeared to be doing nothing at all.
Confidence Is an Emotion, Too
We spend a lot of energy warning investors about fear, and rightly so. Confidence gets far less scrutiny, which is a shame, because it is every bit as much an emotion and it is considerably better at hiding.
A long run of outperformance breeds confidence. Confidence relaxes into complacency. Complacency quietly becomes concentration.
And here’s the trap: concentration doesn’t require a decision. Nobody sits down and resolves to bet the house on seven technology companies. It happens through appreciation, one strong quarter at a time, until a carefully designed portfolio has drifted into an unintended wager.
The longer a trend runs, the more permanent that leadership feels, and the harder it becomes psychologically to hold on to the parts of your portfolio that have been sitting on the bench. Which is precisely when holding on matters most.
Built to Sway
Skyscrapers in earthquake country are not built to resist the shaking. They are built with give. Engineers design deliberate flexibility into the structure so the building can move with the forces acting on it, and that give is exactly why it is still standing when the ground stops moving. Rigid buildings crack. Buildings with structural variety sway and survive.
That’s diversification. It’s structural give, engineered in from the start, so no single tremor determines the outcome. It also happens to be an opportunity strategy as much as a defensive one. Somewhere in your portfolio right now, quietly underwhelming, sits a future leader. We stay exposed to it precisely because we cannot identify it in advance.
The Price of Admission Is a Little Regret
If you’re diversified, something you own will almost always be disappointing you. That’s not a bug in the design. That’s the design. Owning assets that behave differently guarantees that they will, in fact, behave differently, and you’ll notice it most in whichever one is currently bringing up the rear.
Hindsight will always produce something you wish you’d owned more of. Accept that as the modest fee you pay for not needing perfect foresight, which is the one thing no investor has ever actually possessed.
Rebalancing Keeps the Promise
This is where discipline stops being a philosophy and becomes a calendar item. Rebalancing is the mechanism that trims what has run up, redirects toward what has lagged, and restores the portfolio to the weights we designed on purpose. It prevents yesterday’s winners from becoming a disproportionately large share of your future, and it preserves your exposure to the frontrunners tomorrow has not yet revealed.
So no, diversification did not stage a comeback this year. It has been on the job the whole time, doing the unglamorous work of making sure your financial future doesn’t hinge on any single guess. We diversify because we don’t know what we’ll need next. Historically, that has been a very good thing to admit.
